Death of a Renegade
Reviewed By Janet Mawdesley November 21, 2026
Author John Pilkington

Distributor: Amazon
ISBN: 978-1806009633
Publisher: Boldwood Books
Release Date: 3 November 2026
FaceBook: https://www.facebook.com/boldwoodbooks
YouTube:
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/boldwoodbooks/
X Formally Twitter: https://x.com/BoldwoodBooks
Master of sixteenth century murder, John Pilkington continues the Bishopsgate Ward Mystery series in the Death of a Renegade with the threat of the Spanish Armada once again heading for British shores. It was a Spanish Wind which blew no good and it would seem the adage could be true once again.
Matthew Cutler and the other Constables of Bishopsgate Ward have been ordered to draw up lists of men for a muster to be trained to fight against the Spanish should they land on British Shores. They, along with the townspeople are none too happy about this and when the newly appointed Commander of the muster, War Hero Captain John Tilton arrives they are more than ever disturbed by his attitude.
When a man is shot dead at point blank range at the ‘mock battle’ reluctantly held on Mile End Green, the three Constables are convinced the man was murdered, but why is a complete mystery. As if life was not complicated enough, thinks Matthew Cutler, he now has this to try and sort out.
As he digs deeper into the dead man’s life, he discovers the family are of the Catholic faith, with links to the tenants of Fox’s Folly, Sir Gilbert Templeman and his son, which does not make the death of Thomas Cartwright any easier to explain, other than to be Papist in such times as these was a very dangerous thing to be. Could this be linked to his death and if so how.
A second death, at the second ‘mock battle’ once again for no apparent reason, leads the Matthew and the Constables to a tragedy that confounds and places them all in a moral dilemma as to what must be done and what should be done.
Woven carefully through the plot of an obsessive man, there is the everyday life of Matthew Cutler, a man with a conscience, his family and friends which adds a little levity to the tragedy unfolding, as Matthew has also been inveigled to go back to his former profession to act in his friend as well as local Constables play, ‘A Kettleful of Knavery: a nice twist and play on words for the real plot unfolding, which as it turns out could well be just that!
Once again, a most enjoyable return to the 1600’s courtesy of John Plikington as he weaves a very tangled web throughout the town of Bishopsgate Ward, London 1596 with Death of a Renegade.